This page compiles the hands-on testing we have already published in the individual reviews. It adds no new measurements: every score, spec and figure below comes from the linked review.

Avid Power

Avid Power AC/DC Portable Air Compressor

4.3 out of 5

The most flexible compressor under $70: AC power at home for garage duty, 12V for roadside emergencies. It gives up a little speed and gauge accuracy for that versatility.

VIAIR

VIAIR 88P

4.7 out of 5

The most honest 12V compressor for the money: fast, robust and reliable, as long as you accept a screw-on chuck and an analog gauge that reads about 2 PSI high.

Sub-scores from our reviews

The five dimensions behind every overall score on this site, taken verbatim from each review. A dash means the review does not publish that sub-score.

Sub-scores for Avid Power AC/DC Portable Air Compressor and VIAIR 88P
DimensionAvid Power AC/DC Portable Air CompressorVIAIR 88P
Inflation speed4.24.8
Gauge accuracy3.84.2
Build quality4.44.8
Portability3.64.3
Value4.44.6
Overall score4.34.7
Typical price$59.99$64.99

Specifications both publish

Published specifications for Avid Power AC/DC Portable Air Compressor and VIAIR 88P
SpecAvid Power AC/DC Portable Air CompressorVIAIR 88P
Maximum pressure150 PSI120 PSI
Air flow1.4 CFM at 0 PSI on AC, 1.3 CFM on DC1.8 CFM at 0 PSI
Power source120V AC wall power and 12V DC cigarette plug12V DC, alligator battery clamps, 9 ft cord
Hose length3 ft hose with 1 ft extension16 ft
Duty cycle15 minutes on, 10 minutes off25 minutes at 30 PSI, 72°F
Weight4.9 lb (2.22 kg)4.5 lb (2.04 kg)
Included adaptersPresta adapter, ball needle, nozzle adapter, carry casePresta valve adapter, sports needle, plastic storage case

What you accept with each

Avid Power AC/DC Portable Air Compressor

  • Analog gauge read about 2.5 PSI high in both modes
  • Bulky and heavier than a pure 12V inflator — 4.9 lb
  • No auto shut-off, so you still have to watch the dial
  • AC cord is only 5 ft, which often means an extension cord

VIAIR 88P

  • No auto shut-off, so you must watch the gauge and stop it yourself
  • Analog gauge read roughly 2 PSI high against our calibrated tester
  • Loud at close range; roughly 88 dB at one meter
  • Battery clamps mean opening the hood rather than plugging into a 12V socket

Which one, for whom

Choose the Avid Power AC/DC Portable Air Compressor if you weight the trade-offs below more heavily, and the lower price ($59.99 against $64.99) matters.

Choose the VIAIR 88P if you weight inflation speed, gauge accuracy, build quality, portability, value more heavily.

Neither is a bad unit — both cleared the same protocol. Read the two full reviews before deciding: Avid Power AC/DC Portable Air Compressor review and VIAIR 88P review.